April 10 – Cu Chi Tunnels
Our trip to Cu Chi left at 8:30 am and the bus was full. I wondered how Americans would be treated in Vietnam and I felt surprised and slightly comforted to see our guide, Giang, wearing an ‘Obama 2008’ hat.
Giang said that the Vietnamese refer to it as the “American War” but he calls it the ‘Civil War’ as the war was between the North and South Vietnamese.
As Giang explained it, the North and South fought from 1954-75. In 1955, the US came to help the south and there were few US troops in Vietnam from 1955-65. Then in 1965, the US sent 125,000 troops to Vietnam. Giang said America’s mistake was helping to build a corruptive Vietnamese Government that was headed by a Catholic president. This president was very anti-Buddhist and was known for terrible atrocities against Buddhists. A Catholic president didn’t go over well, considering most Vietnamese are Buddhists. When he destroyed temples and killed monks, it only got worse.
The US sent $1 billion/year to help South Vietnam but withdrew their troops in 1972. Vietnam carried on fighting until 1975 when Saigon fell on April 30 (this is now celebrated as ‘Reunification Day’).
We bought our tickets (65,000 dong each) and walked to a small building where we watched a propaganda film about the “American War”. The film was supposedly made in the 1960s but I found that strange considering it showed Cu Chi as a lush jungle full of trees and nature. Cu Chi was a ‘free fire zone’ during the war and was carpet-bombed by US pilots, thus destroying all the trees. Even our guide confirmed the area was pretty bare until the 1980s. He also found it unrealistic that the film featured a young girl smiling at the camera while she took aim at the “American devils”.
Cu Chi looked – and felt – like the Vietnam I’ve seen in films. It was hot. It was humid. There were big centipedes and bugs everywhere. And because of the firing range there, we could hear constant gunfire. Just being there a few hours gave me a whole new sympathy for Vietnam veterans.
The people of Cu Chi created this large tunnel network using homemade tools – something like a garden hoe and a bamboo basket to remove the dirt. The tunnels were booby-trapped and had small passages and large rooms where people lived and hid out. It’s impressive to see what they created – and also the kind of weapons they devised with what they had. I think I’d rather be shot than be attacked with the Viet Cong’s weapons – bamboo spikes that ripped through flesh.
They have recreated tunnels for tourists. These ‘tourist size’ tunnels still make you feel claustrophobic. We entered through a deceptive large area and walked down steps – then before I knew it I was down on my hands and knees crawling through the dirt. I was glad Matt had brought his flashlight. We decided one tunnel was enough and opted out of the second one (as did most of our group). The second tunnel had a 20 meter section that was complete darkness. No thanks!
Matt and I did take up the opportunity to shoot an M-16 while we were there (10 bullets for $13 US). Being American, my natural skills came out on the firing range. Just kidding – the targets were so full of holes there was no telling where our bullets went. I can say that holding an M-16 was awkward. It was a big gun and not lightweight either. When I fired it kicked back a little against my shoulder. And it was so loud (even with the headphones!)
I asked Giang how the North and South are different today.
“North and South people have different characteristics,” he said.
“You mean the South are friendlier?” I asked.
“In short, we don’t like them (North Vietnamese),” he replied.
I asked Giang how he marked Reunification Day.
“It’s not really a celebration day for us. More like Losing Day,” he laughed.
Giang told me that before the war his family had a house in Saigon. His father was a doctor and his mother was a teacher. After the war finished, his family lost their house and was forced to be farmers in a small village.
He said even today North Vietnamese are given priority for government jobs and there’s still a lot of hostility and resentment.
When we returned to Saigon (btw, officially the city was renamed Ho Chi Minh City after the war, but locals call it Saigon) we went for another dose of propaganda at the War Remnants Museum. This museum used to be called the War Crimes Museum, so that gives you an idea of what we saw. There were some very graphic images of people (including children) affected by Agent Orange. It included pictures and stories about the “American devils” (oh, and also the French – they were bad, too!). I found it ironic that one exhibit was sponsored (re: paid for) by a group in Kentucky, USA. Interesting. Vietnam has a way of presenting just their side and it’s not particularly fair or balanced. They really accept no responsibility for their part in any war. They are portrayed as the innocent victims. I’m not saying America was completely altruistic (or innocent), but there are plenty of Americans who protested the war – and plenty who fought to help the South Vietnamese.
I’ve never seen such a biased account in a museum. It must be hard for the Vietnam Veterans who visit.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment